The November 16, 2005 cover story in the Wall Street Journal: “Behind ‘Shortage’ of Engineers: Employers Grow More Choosy” by Sharon Begley is topical and poignant. Ms. Begley describes a situation where employers from a number of companies in the technology sector are feeling the pressures of hiring quality engineers (or the term you read here first; Q-Talent) in a market that hiring professionals feel is shrinking (again lack of quality engineers). Ms. Bagley’s statistics actually show that we have increased our number of engineers entering the market place annually from U.S. universities by 85% from 1998 to 2004 with engineers having nearly the same unemployment rate as other professional positions.
So, what’s the rub?
It well could be that the demand is outpacing the supply. That should not be discounted. However, as the story also states, employers have been much more “picky” in their qualifications requirements. Very specific criteria is being used to screen through candidates today more than ever. Technology is allowing us to do that. Search on ‘keyword’ requirement can drive an entire screening process and negate anyone who does not have that particular skill, experience, course work, etc. On the surface, this seems “okay” as companies are doing their best to find the perfect candidate for critical roles. But, instead what is happening is that technology that is not as smart as the reasonable person is missing potentially great talent – people who can be trained and learn. Yes, they may not have the perfect experience set, but which one of us did when we changed jobs, or got our first jobs? Had we not had the opportunity to actually tell someone who we were, what we could do, and show our passion for the company and the job, we probably wouldn’t have gotten the job.
So, here we are in 2005. Technology has done great things for us. We have gotten better in many ways; we are faster, we are more efficient, we are more cost conscious, but in the way that matters the most, we are still missing the mark. We need to get back to something that we have said for a long time, “before they were candidates, they were people”. Maybe it’s time to revisit the Golden Rule and walk our Staffing leaders through what that means for recruiting and the identification and assessment of Talent. Beyond the front end screening, we also need to take some time to reassess what the message is that we are sending to our potential candidates (and potential customers) with the level of welcoming that occurs at your website and the timeliness of responses (if there are responses) and the staffing process itself.
The market is simmering again and with little or no warning it breaks to a boil. When that happens, it will be the companies that get the big picture who will win.
There is no better time than now to be in constant readiness.